• Why Buy From Benchmark?
    • All Cars
    • All New Arrivals
    • Recently Sold Cars
    • Consignments
    • Merchandise
    • Restoration Services
    • Restoration Policy
    • Restoration Projects
      • '30 Ford 5 Window Coupe
      • '64 Chevrolet Corvette
      • '64 Chevrolet Corvette
      • '60 Chevrolet Corvette
    • Restoration and Customization Overview
    • Performance Upgrades
    • Detailing
    • Storage
    • About Us
    • Our Staff
    • In the News
    • Partners
    • Contact Us
    • Join Our Newsletter
    • Location and Hours

Why Buy from Benchmark Classics?

Why Buy From Benchmark Classics?

The Benchmark Difference ®

At Benchmark Classics, we strive to be the only source you’ll ever need to buy, sell, or restore a classic vehicle.  We are the Benchmark against which our competitors aim to achieve.  Here’s why:

  • Buy from someone you can trust.

We know that you worry about the integrity of sellers of classic cars.  We know firsthand what it’s like to buy from dealers who cannot be trusted.  What did we learn from the experience?  Don’t buy from them!  We know that you would make the same decision about us if we gave you any reason to question our commitment to offering you the finest collector vehicles.

At Benchmark Classics, we pride ourselves on the extensive business experience of our founding partners.  We differentiate ourselves from 99% of our competition with over 100 years of combined business experience.  Two of the three managing partners are CPAs, and both have served as officers at Fortune 500 companies.  The third partner has started several successful businesses, the first of which he founded at the age of 12.
From your first step into our showroom to the moment you bring home your classic, we aim to give you 100% satisfaction.  In fact, the only way we can survive in such an intensely competitive industry is to keep our customers happy so they buy from us again and again.  If you ever have any issue with a vehicle we sell, we will do everything in our power to make the situation right.

  • One of the best restoration teams you’ll find anywhere.

We have put together a world-class group of restoration and service experts that will bring out the best in your vehicle.  We offer a full line of paint services, including custom paint, murals, airbrushing, pinstriping, and single to three-stage paint by none other than Pete Driese.  Your car’s paint will look newer than new!  Rich Schulenberg is our Body Specialist and has been restoring cars since the 60’s.  Tim Marotz is our Master Mechanic who specializes on drive trains and electrical work.  Finally, Mike Frame is our Metal Specialist.  You name it, we can do it!
Want to see our work for yourself?  Take a look at some previous restoration projects here.

  • Consign your vehicle with an unbeatable deal.

If you are looking to sell your classic vehicle, let us help you get top dollar out of it.  You will benefit from all of the full-scale advertising that we give our cars.  Before we promote your car on our website, we will professionally detail the vehicle at no extra cost to you.  Our professional photographer will take high-quality pictures of your vehicle, inside and out.  Your car will then be added to our website, and we will write an expert description of it for you.
Not only that, but your vehicle will be advertised through all of our channels… at no extra cost to you! In addition to our website, we currently advertise in ten publications and websites that reach hundreds of millions of perspective buyers worldwide.

In addition, you will receive digital copies of the high-resolution images of your car!
Now you might be thinking that consigning your vehicle at Benchmark Classics is going to cost a fortune.  That’s not the case at all!  We charge 7% of the sales price for the first $50,000 and 5% for the remainder the purchase above $50,000.   Not so bad, is it?
Of course, if you are looking to turn in your classic for something a little different, we welcome trades!

  • Free shipping now available!

Call us today to learn more about free shipping.

  • Don’t take our word for it – read customer Testimonials:

I purchased a 1958 Cadillac Model 62 four-door hardtop - a very original, unrestored car from the folks at Benchmark in August of 2008. I have been buying cars for the last 50 years and dealing with the folks at Benchmark was the most enjoyable car buying experience that I have ever had. When doing the deal it was discovered that an error was made in posting the price of the car. The owner, Justin Cole, was very up front about the problem and he honored the price at considerable cost to them. Also at the time of the purchase the people at Benchmark noted there was a slight misalignment of the roll down windows on the passenger side. They took the time to remove the inside door panels and adjusted it at no cost. I have the utmost trust and confidence in the folks at Benchmark to make any restorations and/or repairs to my '58 Cadillac based upon my dealing with them.

Marc, WI

I would like to say my experience with Benchmark Classics has been both professional and satisfying. My '68 Cuda arrived as described, an AWESOME car. Justin and his crew handled the transaction promptly and efficiently. I would have no problem whatsoever buying another car from Benchmark! 

Steve, CT

It was a weekend when my wife and I stopped by to look at Benchmark Classic cars but the doors were locked for the day. We decided to window shop. While doing so a sales associate noticed us and re-opened the showroom, turning all of the lights back on. Even though it was after hours the sales associate took his time and let us walk the entire showroom, and what a showroom they had! At no time did we feel pressured into buying anything. In talking with the sales associate we could see his love for classic cars. He had invited us back to talk with Justin, one of the three co-owners. When I met Justin I felt like I had known him for years. Justin had given me some of his history and life-changing experiences that led to where he is now. This kind of treatment was relaxing and instrumental in my decision to purchase an investment car from Benchmark Classics. I would recommend anyone looking to purchase a classic to stop by and just walk through the showroom. You will feel welcome from the minute you walk in.

William, WI

Justin; Thanks for the speedy reply. You obviously have a strong passion for your business and clients. I now have no concerns about buying a vehicle from you site unseen. "Boss Mustang or Shelby" priced right, but near perfect #1, or 2+ condition car. Show only (#1) / show with seldom drives (2+)....as a comparison the Camaro is an even #2 car. My mistake on the option vs. period correct add-on, not my guys. I take full responsibility and apologize. Ferrari has no such add-ons at Parts departments so it is all new to me, but that is no excuse. The fellow is well versed in Camaro details, has both books you refer to, and is a judge at the Camaro Nationals. I simply misunderstood. My bad. There were a few ultra-rare 68 and 69 camaros factory built with the option...on the camaro web-site, too Thanks very much. The car is awesome. Apparently so's the business you are running. Kindest.

Carl, London, ON 

IT'S HERE !!!!
I LIKE IT !!!
IT'S AS GOOD AS EXPECTED !!!
THANK YOU !!!
-55 Nomad

You weren't kidding when you said that the pictures did not do this car justice!
-69 Super Bee 

Love the Charger!!
-69 Charger

Car was excellent, after sale seller made some extra repairs at HIS request!!!
-58 Vette

very easy and very helpful in making the transaction effortlessly
-79 Trans AM

A++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++===
-77 Road Runner